Tactical Mistakes made by Haig The Battle of Somme created dissatisfaction within the British political establishment. InHaig was one of the founders of the Royal British Legion, becoming its first president, a post he held until his death, and helped introduce the poppy of remembrance into Britain.
Sources B and C contain contrasting accounts of the first day of the battle. The question remains however would the extra six weeks to prepare made a difference?
Somme was a strategic point for the German forces to advance further and Haig was determined to halt their advance. A German would be better placed to talk about the effects on the country, and this Source provides an opinion from a different viewpoint.
Haig was confident that he would win the battle easily. Germans had robustly constructed their concrete bunkers. It was believed that the British Forces suffered heavy losses because of the flaw in the tactical moves of Haig.
Cavalry man A Presbyterian and firmly believing that God was on his side and therefore his decisions had to be right, Haig insisted on full frontal attacks, convinced that victory would come by military might alone. Because of this, this source is useful for a historian.
He championed the rights of ex-servicemen and refused all state honours until the government improved their pensions, which duly came in August However, he did not put the lives of his forces in danger intentionally.
Source G is written two months after the start of the battle and it seems Lloyd George is positive about the progress that has been made so far. Despite plenty of careful planning many losses were sustained by all parties.
They were thwarted however by the French Army and were pushed back and a front-line was established. Source H written by the same person is contradictory to his previous account and claims the whole attack was a failure. An expert horseman, he once represented England at polo.
Haig did not realize that he had to face the artillery and machine guns from German troops. Designed by sculptor, Alfred Frank Hardiman, and eight years in the making, it won many plaudits and prizes but unfortunately, the stance of the horse is that of one in the process of urinating.
History No-one expected the First World War to last very long. AboutBritish troops were killed in addition to the French casualties ofDavid Lloyd George, prime minister of a coalition government from Decemberhad questioned the point of launching another costly offensive at Passchendaele but Haig had got the backing of the Conservatives within the coalition and so got his way.
During the tenure as commander of the British Expeditionary Force, he became controversial for his actions. However, he won many battles for the British Force with effective planning and tactical moves.
The Total Allied Forces hadcasualties,of them were British, while the Germans lostmen. It resulted in the loss of about 60, British soldiers in a single day on the 1st July Many of the artillery did not explode.
Journal of Strategic Studies 21 1. Did General Haig attempt to achieve something at the Battle of the Somme, or was he a butcher who sent thousands of men to their deaths?
Yet the very nature of warfare during meant that offense was no match against deeply entrenched defence; the weapons of defence during the First World War were much superior to the weapons of offense.
French forces attacked the Germans from the other side. At least 20, of them were killed. However, to the utter surprise of Haig, the advance artillery bombardment failed to destroy the German front line attack.
Source D also says that General Haig was incompetent.Field Marshal sir Douglas Haig as The Butcher Of The Somme Essay - Field Marshal sir Douglas Haig as The Butcher Of The Somme Sir Douglas Haig was appointed Field Marshal of the British Army inas no progress had been made sincewhen the First World War began.
The issue of Douglas Haig’s role as a general on the Western Front, during the Battle of the Somme inhas been thoroughly questioned by many historians to date. Through different views and opinions, Haig’s skills have been both heavily celebrated and criticised.
More Essay Examples on Army Rubric. Field Marshal Douglas Haig was a senior commander in the British army during World War I - Field Marshall Haig: 'Butcher of Somme?'Essay introduction? He was a warrior with difference.
Feild Marshall Haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of Decemberhe was fifty-four at the time and he had had a very succesful military career. Haig decided to attack the Germans at the river Somme in to attract German soldiers from the town of Verdun where they were fighting the French and had almost broken through.
Essay on The Battle of the Somme, The Battle of the Somme, Comprising the main Allied attack on the Western Front duringthe Battle of the Somme is famous chiefly on account of the loss of 58, British troops (one third of them killed) on the first day of the battle, 1 Julywhich to this day remains a one-day record.
Field Marshal Haig: “Hero or Butcher of the Somme” I consider the field marshal as a butcher and a hero for numerous reasons. While the insinuation of Haig as a butcher ignores many positives that he possessed, the implication of him being a hero also neglects negatives that the field marshal obtains.Download