Although Jing Mei and Maggie do share some similarities, in the long run, they have more contrasting components, like their different family life, self-reliance, and self-motivation.
The most important aspect of her way of parenting is not just fantasizing about the future, but making the future an everyday effort: This young mother has five children, but she only talks about two of them.
My mother believed you could be anything you wanted to be in America. Both stories involve the relationship between a mother and her daughter.
She totally disregards one of them and mistreats the other one. Even though these factors might vary, two people that have very vast backgrounds may actually have similar personalities. Dee would rather distance herself from these "real" people to connect with people of whom she knows nothing—something she believes empowers her, where she feels her American kin do not.
However, on the other hand, the mother treats Maggie as an invisible person.
Hence, there is no perfect way of parenting in a mother and daughter relationship. The author illustrates that both daughters are treated differently, which stems from the relationship that the mother has with them.
She is not aware of who her African ancestors were. There is an important distinction here: Her mother "only [asked her] to be [her] best. Although, after losing everything she loved in life, she still has a positive outlook about things getting better for her daughter.
While the amount of differences between Jing Mei and Maggie are a lot greater, there are still a few evident similarities. The mother, an immigrant, wants to live her American dream vicariously through her daughter by pushing her too hard to be something she is not or desires to be.
This made her mother angry, and in the end it made her give up on Jing Mei. This emotional separation is why the mother treats Dee a certain way. Jing Mei was very young and like most other kids, she hated listening to her mother.
The mother has a successful dream about Dee being something important. This is displayed when she states. You could open a restaurant.
In which, she tries to establish every part of her dreams comes a reality. As far as the reader knows, Dee never changes. You could work for the government and get good retirement.
Jing Mei always though that "unlike [her] mother, [she] did not believe [she] could be anything [she] wanted to be, [she] could only be [herself]. Ironically, in believing she is closer to her "roots" by denying her American heritage, she is actually dismissing the very rich heritage that exists in terms of her American ancestors, and the line of strong women from which she is descended.
Ignoring one daughter over another is wrong, and so is favoring one over the other, especially when the mother is trying to live a personal dream through her daughter. At her job, she picks up secondhand magazines so that her daughter can get a glimpse of the American dream and be able to have the finer things in life.
Everything comes down to communication and love.
Nikan is able to have a vivid image of herself as one of them.Read Comparison Paper on Everyday Use free essay and over 88, other research documents.
Comparison Paper on Everyday Use.
Comparison between the two short stories named I Stand Here Ironing and Everyday Use Tillie Olsen’s I Stand Here /5(1). Start studying short stories quiz. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?" "A Good Man Is Hard to Find" "I Stand Here Ironing" "Everyday Use" List the five types of conflict: Man versus man Man versus self Explain the difference between an.
Comparing Love and Acceptance in I Stand Here Ironing and Everyday Use comparison compare contrast essays Both mothers compare their two daughters to each other. This is what makes the point in the story when she finally does say no (regarding the quilts) such an important moment in Maggie's life.
Short Story Comparison - Two Kinds and Everyday Use.
5 Pages Words November Saved essays Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly! The motherdaughter relationship in I Stand Here Ironing The mother-daughter relationship in “I Stand Here Ironing” To many people, the ideal mother-daughter relationship is not like the one we find in this short story.
Nov 05, · MOTHERS AND DAUGHTERS In the three stories from Mothers and Daughters, “I Stand Here Ironing” by Tillie Olsen, “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan, and “Everyday Use” by Alice Walker, all illustrate how different roles of parenting determine the daughter’s destiny, dreams, personality, and careers.Download